Google has the long-term edge over Amazon in smart speaker platform battle

smart speakers

Artificial intelligence and virtual assistants are expected to be featured strongly at CES 2017, especially smart speakers. According to IHS Markit, that market is going to essentially become a platform battle between between Amazon’s Alexa and Google Assistant – and it’s a battle that Google is eventually going to win, albeit not easily.

Smart speakers are an increasingly important anchor for virtual assistants in the smart home, and expected to grow to a base of 45 million units by the end of 2020, IHS Markit says. But while Google’s ecosystem will help it prevail in the long term, the affordability-based success of Amazon’s Echo Dot is a competitive challenge Google will need to address to succeed, said Paul Erickson, senior analyst for IHS Markit.

“Echo Dot’s inexpensive pricing has proven a volume success for Amazon, and is helping to grow the entire category – and Alexa’s foothold into the mainstream,” Erickson said. “Though Google possesses advantages in the virtual assistant race, Alexa’s Echo Dot-driven surge is a competitive development they will need to respond to quickly. The longer it takes for impulse-buy-priced Google Assistant Smart Speaker products to arrive, the more the future will be one where the Google-Amazon competitive relationship in the virtual assistant landscape will be one of co-existence rather than Google’s preferred position of dominance.”

Despite Amazon’s strong first-mover advantage and momentum, Google Assistant will eventually benefit from (1) scale – a unified presence across all Google platforms, and (2) fundamentals – the ability to enhance consumers’ everyday virtual assistance experience via its strength in search as well as deeper personalization thanks to data from Gmail, Chrome, Maps and other Google services.

Additionally, Google Assistant will be able to play media to the growing multi-brand Google Cast universe of devices – Chromecasts, smart TVs, speakers and Android TV devices.

With Google Home and Assistant both relatively new, these advantages are expected to take time to combine and build momentum, IHS Markit says. Amazon capitalized on this in the fourth quarter of 2016 with a less-expensive Echo Dot, discounted Echo Dot multi-packs, and an aggressive Alexa television ad campaign – to highly successful results in the 2016 holiday buying season.

Echo Dot has become Amazon’s Trojan horse for Alexa penetration into the smart home, similar to Google’s Chromecast and the Google Cast standard, IHS Markit says. Though Google’s advantages are expected to eventually pull Google Assistant ahead in both smart speakers and the overall virtual assistant race, strong developer momentum behind Alexa and surging Echo Dot sales will make this increasingly difficult.

IHS Markit currently estimates 2017 platform shipments of smart speakers at a conservative 4.1 million units for Alexa, and 1.5 million for Google Assistant. Google Assistant is expected to eventually out-ship Alexa by 2020. Despite this, Alexa is still expected to remain the installed base leader in Smart Speakers for several years beyond thanks to the current momentum of Echo Dot.

“Alexa forecasts are expected to be raised further, pending assessment of Alexa-related announcements by third-party manufacturers at CES,” Erickson said. “Given the momentum from Dot’s price-driven success, Google Assistant’s timeframe to catch Alexa in smart speaker shipments will not depend on Google Home, but on when an Echo Dot-priced Google Assistant equivalent will arrive.”

Erickson noted that Amazon is succeeding with Echo Dot and Alexa the same way Google’s Chromecast became the world’s most popular streaming device: “If it’s affordable enough, consumers will take a risk on it. As we enter CES and 2017, we will see if Google responds to Amazon’s mainstream thrust in the smart speaker market by taking its own lesson to heart.”

1 Comment

  1. Google responded at the CES: Powering @nvidia devices and ecosystem with Google Assistant. Appears to be a more open approach than Amazon. The strategy of letting other companies integrate Google’s AI will help speed the uptake by end-customers, while increasing Google’s data gathering and reach.
    Nvidia can work as a intermediary, letting Google AI work together with other 3. party companies that might be considered to be competitors to Google.
    If you are interested in knowing more abouthan ecosystems, their core components and how to create or enter into one, please have a look at our book here:

What do you think?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.